by Chris Bakker, Contributing Writer

After 2022’s Armageddon Time, James Gray returns with another film inspired by the New York City of his youth. Paper Tiger is set in the 1980s, during a time where the Russian presence in America was still being looked at with a fair amount of suspicion, but Gary Pearl (Adam Driver) convinces his brother Irwin (Miles Teller) that there’s also an intent among them to do legitimate business in the States, and he’s found a potentially lucrative opportunity for the two of them to consult with a Russian business.

As you might imagine, when the brothers start to get involved with the Russians things turn out to get a lot more complicated than Gary initially assumed, and the brothers fall down a rabbit hole of illegal activity that starts to threaten their safety and the safety of Irwin’s wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and their children.

Paper Tiger is a throwback to the paranoia thrillers of the time in which the movie is set, and it affects the visual stylings of the era very effectively to truly invoke the feeling that you’re watching one of the classics from the 70s and 80s. What it adds to those stylings is the personal attachment James Gray has to this time and place. It’s apparent in the small things especially; he was the age Irwin and Hester’s kids are in the movie at this time. The way their family is framed as a regular family like any other trying to get by in the world feels intentional. There’s no character among them that feels like a typical movie character; they’re portrayed as real people getting in over their heads.

That’s where the movie is at its strongest; the increasing realization that there’s very little the Pearls can do about the mess in which they’ve gotten increasingly involved. Driver’s performance shines as the perceived cool and successful uncle who’s got everything figured out and tries desperately to keep up appearances. It’s definitely the flashiest performance in the movie because of that, and it’s supported very well because Teller and Johansson play such regular people that were simply chiefly concerned with the wellbeing of their family.

Where Paper Tiger did fall flat for me was with its B-plot revolving around Hester, though I struggle to refer to it as even that much. There’s an environmental thread that runs through the movie that doesn’t so much play as a plot thread as much as it simply offers a set-up and then tries to call back to it with developments in the latter half of the movie. The intent is clear, but the execution of it felt underwhelming to me, and that goes in general for the character of Hester. An actor of Johansson’s standing should get to do more.

Overall, Paper Tiger is a welcome addition to the crime thriller genre, especially with its 80s aesthetic and a tense but suitably understated climax.

Rating: Liked It

Paper Tiger is currently playing in theaters


You can read more from Chris Bakker, and follow him on Letterboxd

Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment now!