by Alice-Ginevra Micheli, Contributing Writer

This review wouldn’t be the first to begin with a commentary on the general cynicism that meets a franchise when it decides to pump out prequels to its previous successful properties. Especially with one as systematically dour as The Hunger Games. Audiences would be forgiven for thinking that there doesn’t seem much of a point for us to revisit stories that must live in darkness, to allow for the light at the end of the original series’ tunnel. However, the appetite for a story such as this has been in active conversation, so the real question is, does it uphold the expectations that have been set?

Taking the world of The Hunger Games decades before Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence) ever set foot in an area, Sunrise on the Reaping follows instead her mentor, Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) as he enters as tribute into the Second Quarter Quell. 

It’s difficult when the hopes of a fandom lie so heavily upon an adaptation’s shoulders, and this is especially true for Sunrise on the Reaping, wherein it was announced at the same time as the book upon which it’s based, released for the first time. So, fans had an entire year to anticipate seeing what they had only just read, emotions being set at an all-time high.

However, as with any adaptation, changes are required to fit an average runtime, and classification. With the Hunger Games movies always looking to be within a PG-13 rating, a certain amount of sanitization has to take place, as what may work for young adults in the written form, is certainly not allowed for the same audience at the cinema – strange as that may seem.

So, with all the expectations on adaptation set, and tempered, the question remains as to whether or not this is a good one. Similar to its predecessor, Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, the answer is somewhere in the middle. 

Where the originals had time to really build up characters, and their interpersonal relationships, this film suffers from a too fast pacing, which rushes through its events in order to get the story told in under three hours. In one film, we have to be introduced to a whole new cast of characters – or at least a version of ones we’ve met that we haven’t seen before – and then witness them as they go through their own reaping, training, Hunger Games, and aftermath, while also taking in all the elements that make it connect to the original story. Even typing that out was a big ask, let alone getting it all on screen in a way that would be entertaining for an audience to watch. 

Unfortunately, as a result, it suffers from its own frenzy. If one is a big fan of the rest of the series – both books, and film – they will definitely get more out of this than if one is coming in as a casual viewer. However, the built-in audience will still end up disappointed due to the aforementioned sanitization of the horror, and violence that makes such a story so affecting.  

A lot of those beats are still there, certainly, but they’re never taken to the level that’s needed to truly result in its intended impact. Even down to the amount of blood that is present in what should be quite visceral deaths is both unbelievable, and insubstantial enough to potentially pull many a viewer out of the screen, and away from what should be an emotionally impactful moment. 

On the other hand, the performances delivered across the board are affecting enough to help bring audiences right back. The star of the show is quite literally the star, being one Joseph Zada. Still relatively new to Hollywood, Zada puts on a masterful performance as Abernathy, somehow both embodying the character many came to know, and love through Woody Harrelson, while also putting his own spin on it. It’s impossible not to be with him every step of the way. Not just because he’s in almost every scene, but also because his acting is truly that incredible. Nothing is left on the table here, which is what is needed for such a tragic protagonist to be believable. McKenna Grace also deserves special mention as Maysilee Donner, a new character to the Hunger Games universe. Playing a seemingly unpleasant person, she expertly weaves the nuance of her character from the moment she is seen until the end. Carrying a strength that Zada’s character often has to borrow, the moments of vulnerability really manage to catch one off-guard as is needed from time to time. 

Jesse Plemons, Kieran Culkin, and Kelvin Harrison Jr, who play, Plutarch Heavensbee, Caesar Flickerman, and Beetee Latier respectively, also deserve an applause for somehow both playing homage to the original characters they’ve taken on, while also adding needed depth to both their personalities, and their stories.  

Finally, it should be noted that this is not a triumphant film. This is in fact, a miserable one. A harrowing journey that turns Haymitch from a young boy full of promise into a sordid alcoholic who everyone can barely stand by the time the first Hunger Games movie comes around. In this, the film is successful. The deep set depression that comes upon readers of the novel is sure to be shared by those walking out of the cinema, but in an almost more brutal way. Partly the fault of the rapid pacing that speeds up the events of the story, where readers were able to enjoy the luxury of breathing room, and space between tragic events, cinema viewers are not given such respite. By the end of the film, if one feels like they’re weighed down by a 1,000 pound weight of grief, they’re coming off light.

In a way, this allows viewers to truly get a chance to empathize with Haymitch and find solace in the knowledge that happiness of a kind is around the corner at the end of the original series. However, knowing catharsis is at the end of a 4 movie marathon, might not be enough for some who walk out of this 158 minute exercise in despair. 

Does The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping satisfy expectations? Some yes, and in others it does let the viewer down. For a super-fan, this will be good enough to warrant a revisit in a regular re-watch so that they can feel like they got the full experience. However, for someone who is not really into author Suzanne Collins’ dystopian world, and is more just curious than anything, it might be better giving this a miss until it’s watchable at home with their favorite endorphins-boosting snack. 

Rating: Liked It

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is currently in theaters.


You can read more from Alice-Ginevra Micheli, and follow her on Instagram and Letterboxd

Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment now!