by John Tillyard, Contributing Writer
Madden is yet another sports biopic with an odd structure as the person it’s about isn’t known only for their career in the actual sport. The story is split into three clear acts: his last few years coaching the Raiders, his career as an announcer, and his work developing the video game that bears his name to this day.
This unfortunately means the story starts towards the end of the Raiders’ first Super Bowl-winning season and therefore takes place entirely after John (Nicolas Cage) became famous. This is particularly disappointing for me, as the part of biopics I find most interesting is their life before fame. It’s much more fascinating to see how they first got involved in what made them famous and which single moment was the key to them making it big. Sadly, the writers of this likely knew people would want to see him as an announcer and the face of a video game, since those are the things he is best known for nowadays.
Focusing on three different sections of John’s life is fine; however, it does give the overall structure a slightly disjointed feel. The first third is a typical sports film, then it becomes the life of a sports announcer, followed by a video game origin story. Aside from showing how these events affected John’s home life, there wasn’t much connective tissue between the three acts. It could almost have been three separate stories.
Madden has been a successful coach of the Oakland Raiders under Al Davis (Christian Bale) for several years. However, his wife, Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), fears he is missing out on a lot of important family time with his sons. Meanwhile, the broadcasting world and video game companies are also keen to bring him on as part of their teams as well. Is John falling out of love with the game, or does he need a different outlet to share his coaching knowledge?
With that said, the three sections are all enjoyable in their own ways. The first section replicates John’s finest hour as a coach. The action during the games looks somewhat real because there is plenty of footage of the real game for one thing, but it’s still not a patch on the footage of the actual game shot by NFL Films. Later, a rather harrowing true event involving an opposing player helps show a more compassionate side of John. He wasn’t all about football; he understood that all players were human beings. There are also several scenes depicting John’s home life that suggest he allowed football to take over his life and unintentionally became a slightly neglectful father. It offered an interesting insight into how John may have become obsessed with his job as a coach, and that he ultimately has to decide whether his passion for the sport is more important than his family. Meanwhile, Al tries to convince him to stick with football, and there is a genuine sense of John being stuck between a rock and a hard place.
The middle section covers John’s career as an announcer at CBS, and the narrative quickly turns into a farcical comedy as John struggles to understand the importance of mics and of not talking over others when working in television. They lean heavily on the idea that John isn’t fully focused on what he’s doing or talking about. There is a montage sequence of John alongside Pat Summerall (Joel Murray) making unusual comments about the game they are watching (including one that uses a clip clearly from the mid-90s, but oh well). This could have led to an interesting arc in which football fans gradually embrace John’s odd remarks and come to feel they enhance their enjoyment of the game. Still, instead, they show John making these comments, people cringing at what he’s saying, and leave it there. It just makes him look dumb and as if no one wants him there.
The third act covers his work alongside Electronic Arts (EA) to develop what would ultimately become the Madden NFL franchise. This was quite a jarring shift in tone, as the narrative suddenly became an origin story for a video game. It once again made John look a bit of a fool as we see him listening, mystified, to the techno babble from the EA development team. While it was somewhat interesting to see how they incorporated his own coaching methods and playbook into the game, the section felt much more about the game than about John’s involvement. This part is also intercut, with rather generic argument scenes between John and his wife, Virginia, and there is no evidence that they truly happened, so their purpose here is very unclear.
The makeup and costume department did a good job of making Cage and Bale look like their respective parts; they look just like John Madden and Al Davis did in the late 70s (aside from the faces, which they can’t do much about). However, I’m not sure I can say the same about the performances. Bale does an alright job as Al Davis, and he impersonates Davis’s authoritative voice fairly well; Cage, however, sounds like himself throughout. There is no attempt from him to replicate Madden’s distinctive announcer voice that NFL fans would recognize from years of live games. Why Cage wouldn’t make any effort to impersonate the most distinctive feature of the person whose name is the film’s title is beyond me. My only guess is that Cage made some attempt at the voice in rehearsals, and it was so bad it was distracting, so they told him to stick with his normal voice. It certainly dragged down the performance for me; it doesn’t help that Cage’s overall performance is a bit cartoonish, giving the whole story an almost satirical feel. Bale is far more compelling and serious; he somewhat disappears into the role, though there are still times when I can feel Bale struggling to commit. Just as a quick sidenote, a 20-year-younger Christopher Walken would have been perfect as Al Davis in this. Hahn is another standout performance, even if her character comes across as fairly unlikable in the way she tries to control John’s life.
Madden, on the whole, is a bit of a mess. It’s three narratives in one that don’t have any clear connections, and it runs into the problem a lot of biopics have: the reality of how the person’s life played out doesn’t naturally make a good story. This could have worked if it only covered one part of John Madden’s life, either as a coach, an announcer or a video game developer. Trying to cover all three made everything feel very muddled. There are a few moments that showcase John utilizing his coaching knowledge, both as an announcer and in his work on the video game, but it doesn’t feel like enough to me. A clear throughline of John as a coach throughout the entire story would have helped to weave everything together. Cage looks the part, but his performance makes the whole thing feel like satire, and the fact he’s using his normal voice the whole time makes it very difficult to imagine him as John Madden.
I’m going to sum up my feelings on this film with a Madden-style statement of the bleeding obvious: What I don’t like about this film is that it’s not good, and I think the reason for this is that it lacks quality.
Rating: Didn’t Like It
Madden is currently available to watch on Amazon Prime Video
You can read more from John Tillyard, and follow him on Instagram and Letterboxd