by Samuel Nichols, Contributing Writer

Making a horror-comedy is a difficult tightrope to walk. Frightening and scary imagery and themes mashed with cleverly written dialogue with wit and humor. You might as well try to ride a unicycle and chew gum at the same time. But with the right talent at the head, anything is possible. Maika Monroe delivers in spades as Governess Winifred Notty in Victorian Psycho.

After joining the Pounds family as a governess, Ms. Notty (Monroe) vows that this time will not be like the others. It is clear Notty is not all right upstairs, and that she has some unnatural tendencies towards violent and dangerous actions. These actions begin to manifest in the odd way she teaches the children Drusilla (Evie Templeton) and Andrew (Jacobi Jupe); and they escalate to her strange interactions with Mr. and Mrs. Pounds (Jason Isaacs and Ruth Wilson) as well as the maid Miss Lamb (Thomasin McKenzie). Will Notty make good on her vow to herself or will this be another slip into madness.

With a CV including It Follows, Watcher, and Longlegs, Monroe’s scream queen card got verified long ago. But this is not her usual line of work as she is often the damsel or the hero. In Victorian Psycho she plays a wonderful monster. One part unhinged lunatic, one part doting, and one part confused loner, she holds together a unique performance. When those various personality traits come into conflict, you can see it overriding Notty’s brain and it’s almost like she short circuits. Monroe twitches and her eyes roll back into her head as her mind and her violent tendencies fight for control of the wheel. Evidently, Notty is trying to be a good person, which is evident in how she speaks to herself in her head. But when the monster seizes control, Monroe summons a performance that could kill with a look. Her work in It Follows will likely be her most memorable, but the effort and skill she shows in Victorian Psycho will deserve a second look.

What certainly helps the audience get into Notty’s mind are the editing and score. Various camera angles and tricks disorient the audience and show Notty’s disturbed view of the world. When paired with the gothic tones and style of the Pounds residence, the audience becomes immersed into this terrifying but beautiful reality. My personal favorite trick is when Notty is swinging a rock for brutal reasons early on in the movie, the camera is attached to her arm, and it reminded me of going on some kind of terrible swing set.

Monroe is not the only one operating at peak crazy here. Isaacs and Wilson also have an intensity that I had seen from them previously. They have both played the villain before in shows like The OA and Luther. But they add in a dash of crazy to their usual recipe, which pairs very well with Monroe being completely batty.

But the most interesting supporting cast members are Evie Templeton and Thomasin McKenzie. Drusilla starts out as a sweet and kind child, but Notty’s actions and presence seem to be influencing her down a darker path. Conversely Lamb is probably the closest thing to a normal person in this movie. Not a criminal mastermind and not much of a mind at all, she does not pick up on the hints that all is not right with Notty. But she does see the distress Notty is in and wants to help her. McKenzie brings a warmth to this movie no one else does. It’s a little of sugar to balance out all the spice brought on by the rest of the cast. 

But both of these supporting roles end up a bit undercooked. McKenzie’s Lamb departs the story barely an hour into the story and Templeton disappears for long portions of the movie. Despite their departures, they still leave an impact on the story, but I would’ve appreciated more time to see Lamb’s response to the nuttiness.

When you title your movie Victorian Psycho not ‘Psychos,’ it tells you we will be focusing on one nut job. And getting into one person’s crazed membrane is enough. What I have not mentioned much yet is Notty’s inner dialogue. Listening to her as she comments on her own decisions and the world around here is ultimately what keeps this movie fresh. Her observations are bluntly funny and cruel to herself and others, which help the audience gain some insight into her insanity. Monroe’s delivery of these inner thoughts seals the deal for me and makes this a movie I love.

Rating: Loved It

Victorian Psycho is currently available in theaters


You can read more from Samuel Nichols, and follow him on Letterboxd

Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment now!