by Samuel Nichols, Contributing Writer

Jimmy Stewart is one of our greatest movie stars. The man won an Oscar, served in World War II, and returned to Hollywood to make what is now considered to be a quintessential Christmas movie. There are few legends of Tinseltown with as wonderful a life. So, when I saw the trailer for Jimmy starring KJ Apa as the titular Hollywood powerhouse, I was intrigued. And to be honest, Apa’s facial movements and attempt to recreate Stewart’s classic voice were spot on to me. They were so good I cracked up so much at the trailer it got an eye roll with a smile out of my long-suffering wife. Turns out I should have stuck with just that trailer and just remembered how funny I thought it was before I was disappointed by the actual movie.

Following his Best Actor win at the 1941 Academy Awards, Jimmy Stewart (Apa) feels the call to join the armed forces. Being the son of a serviceman, he feels it is his duty to serve the country and help defeat the Axis powers. He adjusts to the life of a serviceman with ease, yet it still takes its toll. After returning home from the war, Jimmy wonders how he can even go on with life. But he finds his purpose again in a great script from Frank Capra (Max Casella), and he accepts the lead part in It’s a Wonderful Life.

I don’t know what it is about his impression, maybe it’s because I personally think I do a pretty good Jimmy Stewart impersonation. But no matter what he did, I could not stop laughing at KJ Apa’s performance as Stewart. He has the mannerisms and voice down incredibly well. The most impressive subtle detail is how wide his eyes get without looking off his rocker. That detail is not what Stewart is most remembered for, but it was a trademark expression he made often. Apa nails this and many other small details. If it were up to me, I would ring the bell and give Apa his wings for this performance. His respect and admiration for Stewart is clear in how he studied and mimicked the Hollywood hero’s mannerisms and voice. But respect and admiration are not the most important parts of making a movie.

Production company Burns & Co. seemed dead set on letting Apa do most of the heavy lifting. How do I know this? Because they have some many obviously AI generated background shots that I started to wonder if the movie had wandered into Sam Altman’s desktop. I’m sure the water it cost to generate that sunset or that rainstorm couldn’t have been used for literally anything better. How else do I know Burns & Co. didn’t put any elbow grease into this? They hired a writer whose two writing credits are movies without Wikipedia pages and star people you’ve never heard of. Shell out some money, good grief.

Jimmy really feels like there were two decent story ideas that got smashed together: Stewart’s time overseas during World War II and his comeback story making It’s a Wonderful Life. The war story has Stewart running missions, giving inspiring speeches, bonding with his squad, and falling in love. Individually those are all fine pieces to a movie. Overdone? Maybe but there is nothing new under the sun. We could’ve made a fine movie with just those elements. But the real gold is Stewart back home trying to be an actor after he’s seen the horrors of war. This is honestly where Apa’s acting becomes real and is not just an amusing impression you’d find on Saturday Night Live. He has a shell-shocked look and an aggression that works for someone coping with PTSD. The movie spends very little time with Stewart working through his trauma as this all happens in the final twenty minutes of the move, if that. I would have preferred to see a real character study into how Stewart worked through his trauma on the set of It’s a Wonderful Life while giving that iconic performance as George Bailey. 

Ultimately there is too little of a good thing happening here for me to really enjoy. I left the theater disappointed by the movie, but oddly hopeful. At the end of the movie as the credits ran there were a series of clips using the real footage of Stewart as the years go by. He speaks eloquently of his time serving and the joy of making movies. And as the footage rolled on, no one got up from their seats. It was strange, but felt nice as a community to enjoy seeing a great figure’s life play out before our eyes. Stewart’s life is ripe for further exploration on screen, but perhaps the next endeavor can be better focused and not just reliant on the actor portraying him.

Rating: Low Side of Just Okay

Jimmy is currently available in theaters


You can read more from Samuel Nichols, and follow him on Letterboxd

Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment now!